What we still don’t know about Beirut’s port explosion

Beirut, Lebanon (CNN)It’s been a year since one of the world’s largest ever non-nuclear explosions ripped through Lebanon’s capital, killing more than 200 people.

On any given day in Beirut’s worst-affected neighborhoods, theories about the explosion still circulate. No two stories of human tragedy are alike, and most interactions between people here end not with a goodbye, but with an invocation that Lebanon’s ruling elite be toppled.
The political class is, overwhelmingly, blamed for the disaster.
A year after the Beirut blast, survivors are still grieving, still angry, and still waiting for justice
A year after the Beirut blast, survivors are still grieving, still angry, and still waiting for justice
At just after 6 p.m. on August 4, 2020, hundreds of metric tons of ammonium nitrate ignited, sparking the massive blast in the city’s port.
The industrial chemicals had been improperly stored there for years due to the failure to act by successive governments and lawmakers across the political divide. That much is clear.
But for people across Lebanon, there are still many unanswered questions about what led to the tragedy, and there has been no sense of closure in the 12 months since the explosion.
Here’s what we still don’t know.
What triggered the blast?
Because of the many inquiries by journalists and rights groups over the past year, we know that the ammonium nitrate — stored alongside fireworks in a poorly maintained warehouse — was a disaster waiting to happen.
Six urgent letters sent by customs officials since 2014 — the year the material was unloaded at the port under mysterious circumstances — had alerted the authorities to the danger posed by the chemicals.
One was written by a port official in May 2020, just months before the blast. “This substance, if ignited, will lead to a large explosion, and its outcome will almost obliterate the port of Beirut. If the substance were exposed to any kind of theft, the thief would be able to use this substance to build explosives,” warned the document, which was obtained by CNN after the incident.
Beirut’s port is just 100 meters from some of the city’s most densely-populated neighborhoods. The blast destroyed not only a large part of the port, but also left swathes of the city in tatters. The damage was estimated at between $3.8 and $4.6 billion.
It is clear that successive leaders — four governments and three prime ministers — either would have or should have known about the threat posed by the material, and that little was done to address the danger.
But what is far from clear, 12 months on, is what ignited the ammonium nitrate.
A statue representing the Lebanese expatriate is seen in front of a building that was damaged by the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A statue representing the Lebanese expatriate is seen in front of a building that was damaged by the explosion.
Hide Caption
12 of 23
Lebanese soldiers search for survivors on August 5, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Lebanese soldiers search for survivors on August 5, 2020.
Hide Caption
13 of 23
Beirut was declared a “disaster city” by authorities after the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Beirut was declared a “disaster city” by authorities after the explosion.
Hide Caption
14 of 23
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows ruined structures at the port.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows ruined structures at the port.
Hide Caption
15 of 23
A damaged hospital room is seen on August 5, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A damaged hospital room is seen on August 5, 2020.
Hide Caption
16 of 23
This satellite image, obtained by CNN from Planet Labs Inc., shows a massive crater at the site of the explosion. <a href=”https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/05/world/satellite-images-beirut-explosion-before-after-trnd/index.html” target=”_blank”>See the before-and-after pictures</a>
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
This satellite image, obtained by CNN from Planet Labs Inc., shows a massive crater at the site of the explosion. See the before-and-after pictures
Hide Caption
17 of 23
Rescue crews search a street for survivors on August 4, 2020. “People are asking the emergency department about their loved ones, and it is difficult to search at night because there is no electricity,” Health Minister Hamad Hassan <a href=”https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/lebanon-beirut-explosion-live-updates-dle-intl/h_191ad60f239ae9b49e4332022ce8db8c” target=”_blank”>told the Reuters news agency.</a> “We are facing a real catastrophe and need time to assess the extent of damages.”
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Rescue crews search a street for survivors on August 4, 2020. “People are asking the emergency department about their loved ones, and it is difficult to search at night because there is no electricity,” Health Minister Hamad Hassan told the Reuters news agency. “We are facing a real catastrophe and need time to assess the extent of damages.”
Hide Caption
18 of 23
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/live-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-reddit-online-free/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/hd-tv-when-is-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-dates-how-to-watch-on-tv-and-online/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/cbs-live-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-reddit-online-free/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/nbc-live-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-how-watch-free-golf-stream-reddit/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/tvs-live-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-tv-schedule-free-live-streams-times-channels/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/espn-live-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-free-how-to-watch-stream-golf-reddit/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/fox-live-tv-how-to-watch-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-reddit-online-free/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/hd-live-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-main-event-live-streaming-online/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/go-live-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-reddit-streaming-free-twitter/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/streams-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-streaming-online-golf-tv/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/reddit-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-online-golf-free-reddit-golf-online/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/golf-live-stream-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-free-reddit-online/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/hd-quality-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-free-live-stream/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/online-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-streaming-golf-tv-channel-golf/
https://www.xrjapan.jp/advert/hd-tv-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-online-reddit-free/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/2021-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-how-to-watch-full-reddit/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/crackstreams-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-streaming-free-golf-buffstreams/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/watch-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/buffstreams-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/live-golf-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/watch-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free-2/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/kickoff-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free-golf/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/golfwgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free-reddit/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/cbshd-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/watch-2021-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-streaming-reddit-free-golf-online/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/redditstreams-2021-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-golf-online/
https://www.expo15online.com/advert/streams-reddit-watch-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free-reddit/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/watchwgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-coverage-and/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/frewgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-coverage/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-coverage-and/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-coverage-tv/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/how-to-watch-the-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-round-1/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/world-golf-championships-2021-live-streamreddit/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-coverage/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/how-to-watch-the-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-on-tv-and-online-free/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-streaming-reddit-free-online/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/crackstreams-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-reddit-live-stream-online-reddit/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/buffstreams-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/watch-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/watch-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-free-8-4-21/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/2021-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-how-to-watch-full-reddit/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/crackstreams-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-streaming-free-golf-buffstreams/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/hd-quality-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-free-live-stream-8-4-21-golf/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/watch-free-golf-live-stream-reddit-online-thursday-4-augst-2021/
https://hunterrivertimes.com.au/advert/espn-2021-wgc-fedex-st-jude-invitational-live-stream-full-golf-reddit/
Wounded people wait to receive help outside a hospital. Emergency wards were inundated.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Wounded people wait to receive help outside a hospital. Emergency wards were inundated.
Hide Caption
19 of 23
A helicopter fights a fire at the scene of the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A helicopter fights a fire at the scene of the explosion.
Hide Caption
20 of 23
A nurse <a href=”https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/05/middleeast/beirut-nurse-newborns-hospital-intl/index.html” target=”_blank”>takes care of three babies</a> in a damaged Beirut hospital on the day of the blast.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A nurse takes care of three babies in a damaged Beirut hospital on the day of the blast.
Hide Caption
21 of 23
Firefighters work at the scene after the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Firefighters work at the scene after the explosion.
Hide Caption
22 of 23
A man reacts at the scene soon after the blast.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A man reacts at the scene soon after the blast.
Hide Caption
23 of 23
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows the aftermath of the massive explosion in Beirut, Lebanon.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows the aftermath of the massive explosion in Beirut, Lebanon.
Hide Caption
1 of 23
Volunteers conduct research at the explosion site on August 8, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Volunteers conduct research at the explosion site on August 8, 2020.
Hide Caption
2 of 23
A man sits inside a damaged home in Beirut on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A man sits inside a damaged home in Beirut on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
3 of 23
A woman and her sister-in-law show a photo of a missing man on August 7, 2020. Many people were reported missing after the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A woman and her sister-in-law show a photo of a missing man on August 7, 2020. Many people were reported missing after the explosion.
Hide Caption
4 of 23
Rescue workers search for missing people at the site of the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Rescue workers search for missing people at the site of the explosion.
Hide Caption
5 of 23
People remove debris from a house on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
People remove debris from a house on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
6 of 23
A French rescue worker rests on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A French rescue worker rests on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
7 of 23
A man whose legs were injured because of the explosion looks at a destroyed house on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A man whose legs were injured because of the explosion looks at a destroyed house on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
8 of 23
Christelle Helou hugs the coffin of her cousin Nicole in Sarba, Lebanon, on August 6, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Christelle Helou hugs the coffin of her cousin Nicole in Sarba, Lebanon, on August 6, 2020.
Hide Caption
9 of 23
Lebanese soldiers stand guard in front of destroyed ships.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Lebanese soldiers stand guard in front of destroyed ships.
Hide Caption
10 of 23
A woman, whose son was said to be missing after the explosion, waits outside Beirut’s port to receive information from rescue teams.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A woman, whose son was said to be missing after the explosion, waits outside Beirut’s port to receive information from rescue teams.
Hide Caption
11 of 23
A statue representing the Lebanese expatriate is seen in front of a building that was damaged by the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A statue representing the Lebanese expatriate is seen in front of a building that was damaged by the explosion.
Hide Caption
12 of 23
Lebanese soldiers search for survivors on August 5, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Lebanese soldiers search for survivors on August 5, 2020.
Hide Caption
13 of 23
Beirut was declared a “disaster city” by authorities after the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Beirut was declared a “disaster city” by authorities after the explosion.
Hide Caption
14 of 23
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows ruined structures at the port.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows ruined structures at the port.
Hide Caption
15 of 23
A damaged hospital room is seen on August 5, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A damaged hospital room is seen on August 5, 2020.
Hide Caption
16 of 23
This satellite image, obtained by CNN from Planet Labs Inc., shows a massive crater at the site of the explosion. <a href=”https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/05/world/satellite-images-beirut-explosion-before-after-trnd/index.html” target=”_blank”>See the before-and-after pictures</a>
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
This satellite image, obtained by CNN from Planet Labs Inc., shows a massive crater at the site of the explosion. See the before-and-after pictures
Hide Caption
17 of 23
Rescue crews search a street for survivors on August 4, 2020. “People are asking the emergency department about their loved ones, and it is difficult to search at night because there is no electricity,” Health Minister Hamad Hassan <a href=”https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/lebanon-beirut-explosion-live-updates-dle-intl/h_191ad60f239ae9b49e4332022ce8db8c” target=”_blank”>told the Reuters news agency.</a> “We are facing a real catastrophe and need time to assess the extent of damages.”
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Rescue crews search a street for survivors on August 4, 2020. “People are asking the emergency department about their loved ones, and it is difficult to search at night because there is no electricity,” Health Minister Hamad Hassan told the Reuters news agency. “We are facing a real catastrophe and need time to assess the extent of damages.”
Hide Caption
18 of 23
Wounded people wait to receive help outside a hospital. Emergency wards were inundated.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Wounded people wait to receive help outside a hospital. Emergency wards were inundated.
Hide Caption
19 of 23
A helicopter fights a fire at the scene of the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A helicopter fights a fire at the scene of the explosion.
Hide Caption
20 of 23
A nurse <a href=”https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/05/middleeast/beirut-nurse-newborns-hospital-intl/index.html” target=”_blank”>takes care of three babies</a> in a damaged Beirut hospital on the day of the blast.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A nurse takes care of three babies in a damaged Beirut hospital on the day of the blast.
Hide Caption
21 of 23
Firefighters work at the scene after the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Firefighters work at the scene after the explosion.
Hide Caption
22 of 23
A man reacts at the scene soon after the blast.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A man reacts at the scene soon after the blast.
Hide Caption
23 of 23
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows the aftermath of the massive explosion in Beirut, Lebanon.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
This aerial photo, taken on August 5, 2020, shows the aftermath of the massive explosion in Beirut, Lebanon.
Hide Caption
1 of 23
Volunteers conduct research at the explosion site on August 8, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Volunteers conduct research at the explosion site on August 8, 2020.
Hide Caption
2 of 23
A man sits inside a damaged home in Beirut on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A man sits inside a damaged home in Beirut on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
3 of 23
A woman and her sister-in-law show a photo of a missing man on August 7, 2020. Many people were reported missing after the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A woman and her sister-in-law show a photo of a missing man on August 7, 2020. Many people were reported missing after the explosion.
Hide Caption
4 of 23
Rescue workers search for missing people at the site of the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Rescue workers search for missing people at the site of the explosion.
Hide Caption
5 of 23
People remove debris from a house on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
People remove debris from a house on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
6 of 23
A French rescue worker rests on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A French rescue worker rests on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
7 of 23
A man whose legs were injured because of the explosion looks at a destroyed house on August 7, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A man whose legs were injured because of the explosion looks at a destroyed house on August 7, 2020.
Hide Caption
8 of 23
Christelle Helou hugs the coffin of her cousin Nicole in Sarba, Lebanon, on August 6, 2020.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Christelle Helou hugs the coffin of her cousin Nicole in Sarba, Lebanon, on August 6, 2020.
Hide Caption
9 of 23
Lebanese soldiers stand guard in front of destroyed ships.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
Lebanese soldiers stand guard in front of destroyed ships.
Hide Caption
10 of 23
A woman, whose son was said to be missing after the explosion, waits outside Beirut’s port to receive information from rescue teams.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A woman, whose son was said to be missing after the explosion, waits outside Beirut’s port to receive information from rescue teams.
Hide Caption
11 of 23
A statue representing the Lebanese expatriate is seen in front of a building that was damaged by the explosion.
Photos: Huge explosion rocks Beirut
A statue representing the Lebanese expatriate is seen in front of a building that was damaged by the explosion.
Hide Caption
12 of 23
01 beirut aftermath 080502 beirut explosion aftermath 080801 beirut explosion aftermath 080703 beirut explosion aftermath 080704 beirut explosion aftermath 080706 beirut explosion aftermath 080705 beirut explosion aftermath 080707 beirut explosion aftermath 080701 beirut funeral 080702 beirut explosion aftermath 080607 beirut explosion aftermath 080618 beirut aftermath 0805 15 beirut aftermath 080518 beirut aftermath 0805 RESTRICTED17 beirut aftermath 0805 16 beirut aftermath 080501 Port Beirut ZOOM After29 beirut explosion 080422 beirut explosion 080426 beirut explosion 080408 beirut aftermath 080514 beirut explosion 080413 beirut explosion 0804
According to a report by Human Rights Watch, Tarek Bitar, the judge charged with investigating the explosion, is looking into several theories.
One is that sparks from welding works that day caused a fire in hangar 12, the warehouse where the chemical was being stored.
Another is that an Israeli strike was the catalyst, though Lebanese aviation officials reported that local radar systems did not detect military aircraft over Lebanese airspace in the hour or so before the blast, Israeli officials have denied any involvement, and Bitar himself has said the Israel theory was highly unlikely, according to HRW’s report.
Bitar is also exploring the theory that the explosion was an intentional act, according to HRW.
“Speculation that Hezbollah may have wanted to destroy the ammonium nitrate at the port supposedly to hide that some of the ammonium nitrate in the stockpile had been used by Hezbollah’s ally Bashar al-Assad in Syria to produce barrel bombs increased as reporting emerged regarding the connection between the cargo owners and individuals sanctioned by the US for alleged links to Assad,” the report said, referring to an investigative report by local journalist Firas Hatoum.
Hatoum linked the shipment of ammonium nitrate — which that arrived in 2013 and was unloaded the following year — to companies linked to, according to the HRW report, Syrian-Russian businessmen “who have been sanctioned by the US government for acting on behalf of the Syrian government of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.”
Hezbollah has repeatedly denied involvement in the blast.
A man sits in the rubble of a destroyed house near the port, almost a year after the blast.
A man sits in the rubble of a destroyed house near the port, almost a year after the blast.
Several Lebanese factions were heavily involved in Syria’s civil war earlier in the conflict. Affiliates of Lebanon’s Saudi-backed former prime minister, Saad Hariri, materially aided anti-Assad forces for a time. Hezbollah intervened on Assad’s behalf and is widely believed to have helped save his presidency.
Adding to the mystery around the ammonium nitrate is the fact that all of Lebanon’s major political parties have a strong presence at the port.
“Lebanon’s main political parties, including Hezbollah, the Free Patriotic Movement, the Future Movement, the Lebanese Forces, the Amal Movement, and others, have benefited from the port’s ambiguous status and poor governance and accountability structures,” the HRW report said.
“Political parties have installed loyalists in prominent positions in the port, often positioning them to accrue wealth, siphon off state revenues, smuggle goods, and evade taxes in ways that benefit them or people connected to them,” it added.
Was any ammonium nitrate missing? What happened to it?
The judicial investigation’s third theory, that the ignition was an intentional act, has gained prominence over the past year.
Several reports have suggested that far less ammonium nitrate exploded last August than initially thought. According to Reuters, an FBI report estimated that only 20% of the 2,755 tons of ammonium nitrate brought to the port in 2013 actually detonated. The HRW report also cited an August 2020 investigation by the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project in which three European intelligence sources estimated that the size of the blast was equivalent to as little as 700- 1,000 tons.
The theory goes that the ammonium nitrate was left at the port, where it could be siphoned off by factions in Lebanon.
Caretaker Prime Minister Hassan Diab told CNN he only found out about the existence of the ammonium nitrate in early June 2020, and immediately requested further information. He said he received a file on the situation at the port on July 22 — but that the part predicting the catastrophic effects of an explosion had been omitted.
Lebanon’s caretaker Prime Minister calls Beirut port explosion ‘suspicious’
Lebanon’s caretaker Prime Minister calls Beirut port explosion ‘suspicious’
Diab said he forwarded the file to the Ministry of Public Works, under whose purview the port falls, and the Ministry of Justice, and asked them to investigate the chemicals at the port.
CNN has seen a document showing that the Ministry of Public Works stamped the front of the file on August 4, 2020.
The blast happened at 6.08 p.m. the same day.
In a December 2020 interview with CNN, Diab — by then the country’s caretaker Prime Minister — called the timing “suspicious.”
“There is something suspicious for (the report) to come in July 22 … and then for it to blow up. There is something suspicious. Even though this is a seven-year issue. Seven years, for God’s sake,” Diab told CNN at the time. “There’s something that’s unexplainable, the timing of this.”
How will Beirut rebuild?
Perhaps one of the most glaring unanswered questions surrounding the Beirut port explosion is whether the city will ever go back to what it was.
Since the blast, the city has buckled under the strain of a rapidly plummeting currency, long power outages, and severe medicine, milk and fuel shortages. Lebanon’s dire economic straits mean most of the rebuilding efforts have been privately funded, or supported by non-profit organizations. A year later, much of the repair work is still ongoing.
But many home and shop owners say they neither have the financial means nor the psychological strength to return to affected neighborhoods.
“They’ve ruined us. I’d sell my soul to leave this country,” said one shop owner on the once hip but still extensively damaged Gemmayze street, referring to the country’s ruling class. “May they never again see a good day.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *